The Detroit Tigers Tales of Woe Continue
Baseball June 10th. 2008, 6:00pm
Intern Bill, who we may soon put on Willie Randolph watch, is mildly interested at the level of suck the Detroit Tigers have achieved this season. Jim Leyland must be on the hot seat! Oh, whoops, he’s not. The toothless Tigers are 11 games under .500, 11 games out of first, and their pitching staff has the fourth worst ERA in baseball (4.78). Bonderman’s hurt, Sheff’s creaky, and Zumaya, we can only assume, is on Death Cab for Cutie’s tour bus.
It was reported over the weekend that Detroit Tigers starting pitcher Jeremy Bonderman has undergone a procedure to remove a blood clot from underneath his shoulder, effectively ending his 2008 campaign. Meanwhile, Dontrelle Willis, he of the funky delivery, DUI, and 1:4 K/BB ratio, was annihilated last night so badly that today he was sent to A-ball (not even AAA or AA – single A!) in Lakeland, and may eventually come out looking like Rick Ankiel.
Jim Leyland was wishing for the day he’ll be able to abandon the sunken ship that is the 2008 Tigres and start accosting nurses again, Eminem style.
Monday’s game was probably a pretty good summary of the season the Tigers are having, surpassing perhaps even the’07-’08 Chicago Bulls for pre-season excitement and eventual disappointment. Baseball Prospectus has their playoff odds at less than four percent, and while those projections aren’t always correct, it certainly doesn’t paint a good portrait of things to come. This club has the kind of problems we might not have known at the beginning of the season, but we’re starting to figure out pretty quickly.
Pitching – People following baseball had a pretty good idea that pitching would be a weakness of the 2008 Tigers, but no one expected it to be this bad, this quickly. Bonderman stopped striking guys out, Rogers has run out of pine tar, Verlander might be paying for the 223 total innings, including playoffs (!) he threw his rookie year, and Willis has been a flat out disaster. Honestly, did anyone think that Dontrelle was going to work out? The guy was overrated in a pitcher’s park in the NL East, and now he moves to the AL Central? The bullpen and “Little Cat†Armando Galarraga (one of the best nicknames in show business!) have been bright spots, but someone needs to soak up innings, and the fact that Leyland actually drove 60 miles to see if Fernando Rodney and Joel Zumaya are progressing in AAA isn’t all that encouraging on this front.
Defense – When you have a DH trying to play right, a 1B trying to play 3rd, a 3B that can barely play 1st, and a cranky C/3B/RF/etc. playing everywhere, we’re not sure this is a properly constructed roster. These guys are put out there like a fantasy team! Just because Troy Glaus was SS eligible in 2007 in Y! leagues doesn’t mean you’d actually play him there. Not if you wanted to win, at least. CF Curtis Granderson, 2B Placido Polanco, and C “Pudge†Rodriguez (he of the .635 OPS!) can still pick it, but there are still way too many holes in a ballpark of that size.
Injuries - Willis, Sheffield, Granderson, Rodney, Zumaya, backup C Vance Wilson have all spent time on the DL. Part of it is because of age, part of it is because of freak accidents, and some of it is the wear and tear that naturally occurs as a part of the professional baseball season. The problem with giving up so much talent for Edgar Renteria and Miguel Cabrera is that when you need Jair Jurrjens, Cameron Maybin, or Andrew Miller to pick up the slack when injuries occur, they’re too busy winning games for better teams.
So can this crew turn it around? Absolutely. If Verlander starts pitching to his projections, Pudge turns into his pre-2000 self, and the other two contenders fall off the map, it’s possible. But very, very unlikely. The worst part about all this is that they have big dollars committed to a lot of these players, so this is the core they’ll have for the foreseeable future.
And to add even more insult to the injuries, the original Tigers Stadium (tied for the oldest ballpark in the majors when it opened in the early 1900’s) is scheduled to be razed so that the city can develop… a Wal-Mart? An office park? Low-income housing? A shooting gallery that’s not the Detroit City Fire Department? No one knows exactly. But instead of letting companies tear the sainted relic down and sell it for scrap, why not just wait for Devil’s night, when the good citizens of Detroit can burn the place for kicks? Imagine the scene: late October, the hometown nine haven’t played in weeks, and the denizens of D-Town are burning last evidence of relevance the city had on the sport of baseball other than that of a punch line.
It would be a fitting end to the 2008 Detroit Tigers.
21 Responses to “The Detroit Tigers Tales of Woe Continue”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.

June 10th, 2008 at 6:03 PM
Jim Leyland is one of the most successful baseball managers of all-time.
Willie Randolph is, well … Willie Randolph.
Therein lies the difference.
June 10th, 2008 at 6:05 PM
baseball managers are borderline irrelevant man.. where was leyland’s genius in Colorado? willie randolph isn’t the reason they are losing
June 10th, 2008 at 6:07 PM
I think I’d rather hire some dude off the street to manage rather than some famous guy who thinks he has to tinker with the lineup all the time.
June 10th, 2008 at 6:08 PM
@ fetch.. EXACTLY.. the job title for a manager should simply be “sit there, and don’t fuck it up like dusty baker”
June 10th, 2008 at 6:10 PM
All that should matter is what they’ve done at their current stop. Which is basically the exact same. (I think you missed this discussion – it was last month)
June 10th, 2008 at 6:21 PM
Seems so weird that just a couple years ago, the Tiger’s pitching was so strong. Weren’t people calling Nate Robertson the 2nd best lefty in the AL?
June 10th, 2008 at 6:24 PM
thread jack,
hmmmmm…Tim Donaghy told federal investigators that other officials fixed 2002 playoffs specifically the Laker/Kings series. Trying to cover is ass? maybe. but to completely rule it out, foolish. I have always felt that this is bigger than him.
June 10th, 2008 at 6:46 PM
mike…you missed the ugliness between me and TBL which I attempted to fix by accusing him of steroid use by using his own words…well lets just move on…any way TBL..I am off Willie watch until the all-star break per Maggs…so we can wait on that one.
June 10th, 2008 at 6:51 PM
wait breaking news !!!!!!!!!!!!!! the detroit tigers suck!?!?!?! i remember when thay sucked like it was 3 years aog….oh wait..it was 3 years ago. i remember when i wanted the cubs to somehow get miguel cabrera. now im kinda glad we didnt.
June 10th, 2008 at 7:01 PM
bonderman and verlander are prime examples as to why the Yanks have put Joba on a pitch and innings limit. The Tigers played these guys to the max as soon as they got called up.
June 10th, 2008 at 7:03 PM
maybe Illitch should take a look at the other team he owns and realize you win with defense. The Wings had a pethora of scorers before they won in 97. Trade away some of that offense and restock the arms Tiggers.
June 10th, 2008 at 7:40 PM
“The Toothless Tigers”- great! And I am Tigers fan. What, if any, will you say about the Yankees?
June 10th, 2008 at 7:42 PM
and Jimmy came to T-Town on Sunday? Good scoop, Bill, I hope he wasnt buying crack in the wylers.
June 10th, 2008 at 8:16 PM
Dontrelle Wills to SINGLE A!
June 11th, 2008 at 12:17 AM
Not sure how it’s the fault of the manager that he has zero pitching staff.
In other news, Barack Obama is a blithering idiot.
June 11th, 2008 at 1:09 AM
I agree with the sentiment about the Tigers. Though, I think that you missed the big number, $138 Million. That is the Tigers’ payroll for this season.
Also, can anything be written about Detroit without resorting to the violence cliches? Kwame jokes, fine. But the fires and violence jokes are a small step above Bill O’Reilly ridiculing the Black people of New Orleans.
June 11th, 2008 at 2:12 AM
Please supply evidence of O’Reilly making racist comments.
June 11th, 2008 at 8:40 AM
Yeah this is a piss poor peice. If you want to make cracks about a city why don’t you pick one you have actually been to, you cheese dick. Detroit is NOT the gangland you all make it out to be. There is nobody there anymore. You should be ashamed to have run this post, the Tigers are bad, but to link it to a city that has taken this many bumps over the last few years is just stupid.
June 11th, 2008 at 10:24 AM
Clown the Tigers, but not the city of Detroit. That’s cheap.
June 11th, 2008 at 11:36 AM
The old Tigers stadium is being torn down because when the Tigers moved to Comerica Park, the city stopped maintaining it. It’s a wreck on the inside, is unsafe to be inside of it. As for what is going to replace it, who cares? They’re tearing down Yankee stadium this year, haven’t you heard?
As for Maybin and Miller, go check up on them. Maybin hasn’t even made the Marlins MLB roster yet, and Miller used to be 1-5 with a 7 ERA, in the NL.
June 11th, 2008 at 12:40 PM
@dx87: Good points on Maybin and Miller. Jurrjens seems to be the only consistency in the Braves starting rotation, yet he’s proven to be inconsistent (does that make sense?).
It’s a damn shame to see the old ballpark in such shambles. Think of the great moments and players in baseball history there. Ruth hit the longest HR in history there. Maris hit No. 1 of 61. Ripken ended his consecutive games played streak there. Cobb, Gehrig, Gehringer, Jackson, Greenberg, Ruth, Maris, Aaron, etc, etc, etc, etc.
Tiger STadium, then Navin Field, opened on the same day – April 20, 1912 – as Fenway Park. They are the oldest living ballparks.
Tiger Stadium is beyond repair. But at least part of it should be saved. When the year 2400 comes along, people are going to think back at the turn of the century and wonder what architecture was like. But they’ll never know because our current society is so fixated on the next superstore or shopping center that we tear down historic buildings and replace them with retail stores that will probably go out of business anyway.
Look at the remains of ancient Europe – the Coliseum, castles, Parthenon. Why can’t we keep structures in tact or at least partially intact for historical reflection?